Wednesday, 7 September 2016

Europe as a super power?



Albert brought us the Christmas tree and supported a young queen in becoming an effective ruler. Victoria’s mother was German. Yet it didn’t stop two major conflicts within Europe with the UK and Germany on opposing sides. The Great War in fact was sparked by a noble couple being assassinated.
Most conflicts within Europe have come about as a sort of family falling out amongst the royals. To the extent that the Battenburgs were so embarrassed that they changed their names to Mountbatten.  
We mustn’t forget good old Henry: he almost created his own EU in order to get his little nut tree to bear fruit.    
Ironically after the Eton mess that was 23 June 2016 we’re getting the most sympathy from the German chancellor.
It does seem that it works better when it’s left to the people. There has been some squabbling, some jokes about crooked bananas, and lies about why we pay money to the EU but on the whole it’s been extraordinarily good for us, not least of all because we’ve had over 70 years of peace within Europe. You make the effort to understand when you value the trade links you’ve set up and when you’ve actually formed meaningful friendships on a personal level. We’ve bailed out Greece a couple of times. And complained, but what about when we need bailing out? We’ve sympathised and been able to help when France has been attacked by terrorists. And if like me you live in Greater Manchester, you may wonder what our tram system would be like without the EU.
A poll was published in the Sunday Times a few days after the referendum. It showed that several other states would vote to leave the EU. Yet their politicians don’t offer that opportunity because they know that it’s in the best interests of their electorate to keep their nation in. Don’t let your people shot themselves in the foot. Don’t let your child wander into the bonfire.
In the week leading up to the referendum, many of our European peers flew the union flag and posted messages saying “please stay”. Europe wants us in. We are valued. We’ve just slapped the other Europeans in the face.  
The Soviet Union has disbanded but Russia remains aggressive. The US will probably always be our ally but occasionally needs reigning in. We’re opening up to China and Japan but need to be seen as strong. We’re Better Together – that phrase is useful here as well. What if we negotiated with Europe – we’ll stay if you agree to trade freely with these countries? Wouldn’t that make us and Europe a lot stronger?         
Occasionally, one forms a union and agrees to abide by certain rules. Then something comes along and bites at the conscience.  I so wanted to allow Tony Blair to have been in that position over Iraq.  Even worse than the war itself was how it divided the United Nations. Simply put, they were no longer united. It wasn’t right. We know that now.
However, I think we have a different scenario here. I absolutely believe in democracy but did not find the referendum democratic. The 48% “losers” have no representation. Brexit was sold on the back of some despicable lies. Most MPs didn’t want it. They have a duty of care to their electorate.
Finally, the world needs the UK in Europe. I don’t believe as some do that the UK is so great that it can thrive alone. However, I do think we have a lot to offer. Yes, the EU needs some reform. So let’s do it. Let’s let Europe become a super power. Ironically, Tony Blair, of all people, is saying pretty much what I’m saying here. Am I about to forgive him?       

Saturday, 3 September 2016

A post card to the PM and the our MP

On Thursday 1 September Martin and I and hopefully thousands if not millions of others have done the same.
It's actually quite difficult to put on to half of the back of a post card what you think about Europe after being very closely engaged with it for over 40 years.


This is what we wrote:


Dear Theresa May,
You wanted to remain as well.
We are both European.
Being in Europe has been good for us for forty years.
Why this hideous divorce?
Al those young people who want to remain. What about them?
Do the right thing.
Dr Gill James (Speaker of four EU community languages)       
     

Dear Ivan Lewis,
When will you reassure me that the 48% voters in the recent referendum will get some representation? After a general election with one party gaining 52% of the votes and the other 48% that 48% is still represented. Not so, apparently in a referendum. 
Both sides of the Bexit / Remain debate used lies but the particular ones used by Brexit were hideous. And there is no real Brexit plan. Not to speak of the billions we have already lost. 
We vote for you to have our best interests at heart. In fact anyway more MPs wanted to remain that leave. Will you stop us shooting ourselves in the foot?   
Do something before it is too late.
Dr Gill James    



Dear Ivan Lewis,
We voted you into parliament to represent the wishes of your constituents. Yet in the matter of a referendum it seems we are not entitled to such representation. Instead, we have to accept the mis-informed wishes of under half of the UK electorate. This is not democracy.
Leaving the EU will be harmful for both the UK and the rest of the world. We will be throwing away 40 years of progress. Indeed, the majority of MPs realise this, and wished to remain in the EU.
Please do something before it is too late.
Dr Martin James
 








Dear Prime Minister,
You wanted to remain as well.
We are both European.
Being in Europe has been good for us and good for the world for forty years.
Why bow to the mis-informed opinion of under half the population? This is not democracy.
It is not too late to reverse this terrible path.
Dr Martin James






Why do we feel so committed to Europe?

  • we speak five of her languages
  • we have lived and worked in other EU states 
  • we have been very involved with twinning arrangements
  • we have seen poorer countries grow 
  • we have seen wealth created that is more than the sum of its parts
  • we have felt more protected by EU law than by the British law it replaced
  • we're enjoying riding the new tram routes in Greater Manchester (You got it: EU money)    
  • we enjoy travelling through Europe
  • we see a united Europe, i.e. a EU, as more able to fight terrorism 
  • we see a united Europe as a stepping stone to world peace 
  • we cherish the support that a united Europe can to give us in times of trouble
  • we have worked almost continuously for 40 years on helping others to stretch out and take the hand of friendship that crosses language and cultural barriers     
  • we have many friends in Europe - both other Europeans and ex-pats   
Here's what some others said on their post cards:
#StopBrexitPostcard

#60YearsofPeaceinEU

#63%DIdNOTVoteLEAVE

#37%ofElectoratIsNOTaMAJORITY

#BrexitisNOTtheWILLoftheMAJORITY

#FundNHSnotBREXIT

#ParliamentisSovereignNOTaMINORITY

#DON'TLetLiesandaMINORITYRule

#ReferendumwasONLYAdvisory

DontForgetUKCitizensLivinginEU

#DontIgnoreGIBRALTOR

#DontIgnoreScotland

#DontIgnoreNIreland

#DontIgnoreAberdeen
#DontIgnoreBath
#DontIgnoreBelfast
#DontIgnoreBrighton
#DontIgnoreBristol
#DontIgnoreCambridge
#DontIgnoreCardiff
#DontIgnoreDundee
#DontIgnoreEdinburgh
#DontIgnoreExeter
#DontIgnoreGlasgow
#DontIgnoreGuildford
#DontIgnoreHarrogate
#DontIgnoreLeeds
#DontIgnoreLeicester
#DontIgnoreLiverpool
#DontIgnoreLondon
#DontIgnoreManchester
#DontIgnoreNewcastle
#DontIgnoreNorwich
#DontIgnoreOxford
#DontIgnoreReading
#DontIgnoreStockport
#DontIgnoreYork

#DontIgnoreEUCitizensLivinginUK

#DontIgnoreUKCitizensLivinginEUfor15Years

#STOP_BREXIT
Yes, we know the EU's  not perfectly managed, and that there is some dissatisfaction within other states as well. But its a remarkably good concept and worth getting right. My next post will go into a little more detail on this.